Odds of winning summary judgement are also known as the grant of summary judgment.

Odds of winning summary judgement

The main factor which affects your grant of the summary judgment is the presentation of facts in front of the judge, so try to keep the facts in your favor. Read further to know more factors.

What Are the Chances of Winning or Surviving a Summary Judgment? 

The chances of winning or surviving a summary judgment are high if the facts are in your favor and presented correctly in front of the judge. It also depends upon the case type. There is a high probability of winning in civil rights or employment cases.

Judges rarely grant motions for summary judgment. According to one study, summary judgment motions are granted most frequently in civil rights cases. On the other hand, summary judgments in tort and contract law are rarely upheld. Less than 10% of these cases will be successful. 

According to a different study, cases under Title VII, such as those involving equal pay or employment discrimination, are those in which summary judgment is typically granted. In 17% of all federal cases, summary judgment motions are submitted. Plaintiffs filed 26% of the motions for summary judgment, while defendants filed 71% of them. Of all of these, 36% were rejected, and 64% were fully or partially approved.

What Are the Ways to Increase Your Chances of Winning a Summary Judgment? 

The ways to increase your chances of winning a summary judgment include your written materials which must demonstrate to the judge that the facts and law support summary judgment and that there are no errors of fact or law. It will make the judge write the decision easily.

The following are other ways to win a summary judgment. These also answer the question, “How do I survive a summary judgment?

– Preparing for the Motion as Soon as Possible

Expert lawyering requires planning in advance, discipline and aggression at the summary judgment, which should be on attorneys’ minds if they expect to win it. There are some cases, according to some attorneys, where there are slender chances of success. However, a motion for summary judgment has a chance of succeeding.

A lawyer should determine their own probabilities, which requires understanding the evidence right away. A lawyer should use some strategies in order to prevail on a case for summary judgment. Some examples are planning depositions, conducting discovery, using expert witnesses to achieve summary judgment, and having the discipline to concentrate only on aspects that really matter.

In addition, a motion for summary judgment must establish that there is no genuine dispute regarding any material fact. Therefore, “material” belongs in planning, while “real issue” belongs in discipline, in order to successfully prepare for advance through and obtain the desired outcome from the motion for summary judgement stage. One must prepare for a motion for summary judgment from the outset of the case if they hope to prevail.

Taking crucial depositions is part of the diligence and offensive strategy required to defeat a motion for summary judgment. Additionally, attorneys need to take important depositions on time. This is so you can get some very important admissions in an early deposition that will help you on a motion for summary judgment. 

In fact, securing important admissions early can benefit a party even if those admissions are insufficient to support a motion for summary judgment.

– Preparing for the Defence

Before putting together a pertinent defense for the motion for summary judgment, lawyers should take a reactive approach to cases, letting their opponents establish the record and develop legal theories. Such a reactive strategy, however, is doomed to failure.

Preparing for the defence

It is particularly crippling for prevailing on a motion for summary judgment as so much persuading a judge to dismiss a case requires building up reams of evidence in your favor. From the outset of the case, one must ask themselves: Alright, what are the components of the causes of action here? What can you do to claim these crucial components are missing or not discernible? 

Understanding what is relevant to the defenses or claims in the case is important. Furthermore, one must be aware of this from the start in order to ensure that the facts necessary to support a motion for summary judgment are included in the record. Planning your discovery carefully is essential when using an offensive strategy for a motion for summary judgment. 

Furthermore, having favorable facts is helpful in winning a motion for summary judgment, but much of that depends on your discovery strategy and how you go about gathering evidence.

– Preparing for Jury’s Instructions Beforehand

A great way to defeat a motion for summary judgment is to anticipate the issues the jury will face in your case. Most legal professionals have stated that the aforementioned is supported. Writing a strong summary judgment brief is crucial because jury instructions also focus on the most important unresolved issues in a case. 

To address these issues before they are presented to the jury, evidence must be gathered, and arguments must be developed.

Furthermore, a lawyer should review the jury instructions before drafting a motion for summary judgment. This is done to ensure that everyone is aware of the components of each claim and defense and that none of those components are materially in dispute. That’s because you won’t be able to withstand a motion for summary judgment if you can’t eliminate all of the elements.

Jury instructions highlight the key issues in the case, so your main goal should be to establish evidence to support your side’s position on those issues. Jury instructions are the final event in a case, but you must consider them immediately if you want to defeat a motion for summary judgment. As a result, one should consider the jury’s instructions right away. 

– Reducing Complexities in Arguments

Excellent discipline is necessary for effective briefing and oral argument. Narrowly focusing the issues to concentrate on the most crucial aspects of your case will improve your chances of success while trying to win on all claims in a motion for summary judgment. Keep the movement concise and straightforward. 

The opposite strategy is more likely to be successful than the sometimes-perceived necessity to institute a motion for summary judgement on everything or to use summary judgment to tell their story. Keep the motion tightly focused on a straightforward claim element that the defendant lacks in support of, or, on the plaintiffs’ side, the crucial claim element that you believe you have the best chance of winning.

Furthermore, a focused separate factual statement or summary of undisputed facts can make your brief much more convincing to a skeptic judge. When a case for summary judgment is made, the separate statement of undisputed facts is the first thing judges look at. 

Their task will be accomplished if they can pinpoint a single fact in the separate statement that will make them unhappy. The objective must be to present only those facts that are absolutely necessary to your motion and not to be deceived into thinking that you will be able to convince the judge with a large number of uncontested facts.

To win a summary judgment, a party must primarily establish quality rather than quantity. Additionally, simplicity is key. This should be a person’s mantra when making an oral argument.

To present the case to the court, the briefing is also crucial. Having said that, one must resist the urge to respond to each and every point made by the opposing side during the oral argument.

– Judge’s Interest

Analyze the judge’s level of interest. If given enough details about the case, some judges will demonstrate that they are in favor of granting summary judgment. Gaining a summary judgment requires persuading the judge to dismiss the case without a trial. 

Judge court interest

For this, you must have a mountain of convincing evidence on your side. Take all of the important depositions early on in the case to get key admissions from witnesses or attorneys who need to pay attention.

– Additional Considerations

It might be a good idea to abandon the motion altogether if you believe your chances of winning a motion for summary judgment, or even partial summary judgment, are slim. By doing this, you’ll keep your opponent guessing about how you’ll conduct the trial. 

You must believe that your chances of winning the motion for summary judgment are greater than 50%. Because doing so will give the opposing side a road map, preparing the motion and gathering all the evidence is the last thing you want to do before the trial.

Additionally, if you believe that a trial is unavoidable, you should reconsider attempting to undermine your opponent’s tenuous claims through a partial motion for summary judgment. Those defenses could help you in your jury testimony. 

The majority of attorneys claim that they intentionally include false claims so they can later stand up and tell the jury that these claims are false. 

What Happens if You Lose a Summary Judgement? 

If you lose a summary judgment you can appeal for a grant of summary judgment. The losing party may still ask the court to reconsider its decision or order a new trial despite the verdict. They can ask a higher court to review the summary judgment if they so choose.

However, bear in mind that these appeals processes are subject to strict time constraints. There is no longer a window of opportunity to appeal the court’s summary judgment once it has been rendered. The winner can take action to have the judgment enforced.

What Happens When a Plaintiff Wins Summary Judgment? 

When a plaintiff wins summary judgment or if the plaintiff has obtained a summary judgment of liability that benefits the plaintiff, an interest accrues at 9% per year starting the day the judgement is entered. This will encourage the defendant to reach a settlement rather than go to trial.

In many instances, the jury may still review the plaintiff’s actions at the damages trial even after the plaintiff has won summary judgment on liability to determine whether there was any comparative fault on the plaintiff’s part. 

On occasion, the plaintiff will obtain summary judgment and the judge will determine that the defendant is solely to blame for the mishap. In those circumstances, the jury won’t have the chance to determine.

How to Respond to a Summary Judgement to Increase Your Chances of Winning? 

To respond to a summary judgment to increase your chances of winning the non-moving party must file a motion which is a formal request for a decision in their favor and memorandum, which justifies the court’s favorable decision in their favor. It is called the opposition motion or response.

The non-moving party is always given a chance to reply to the summary judgment motion once it is filed. The non-moving party must contest the fact, typically by offering proof, and accept that no facts are in dispute and challenge the petitioner’s legal analysis.

The non-moving party is always given a chance to reply to the summary judgment motion once it is filed. The opposition motion or response is what this is known as. The other party is given a set amount of time to submit a response. States have different time limits, but generally speaking, it lasts three weeks.

– What Happens When a Response Is Filed?

When a response is filed, the judge will read both the motion and will then conduct the hearing. Each party will have a set amount of time during the hearing to restate their case in front of the judge. The judge may ask some questions.

What happens when a response is filed

The court will decide whether to grant or deny the motion at the final hearing. One of the results of the summary judgment process is the settlement after summary judgment granted.

FAQ

1. How Long Does It Take for a Judge to Rule on Summary Judgement?

To rule on a summary judgment, a judge normally takes one to three months to review the legal briefs and rule on a motion for summary judgment. After the parties have filed their legal briefs and, if necessary, held a hearing on those briefs, this time frame doesn’t start.

If the case has complicated issues, the judge might take longer.

2. Is a Summary Judgment a Final Judgment

A summary judgment is not a final judgment because, in case of final judgment, you can file an appeal against the summary judgment, which begins the trial of the case. Below mentioned is the para which throws light upon summary judgment vs trial.

Motions for judgment and summary judgment are very similar in that parties in both motions ask the judge to rule in their favor on one or more issues. However, because judges apply the same legal standards when deciding these motions, they differ because they are made at different points in the course of a civil case. 

JMOL is an in-trial or post-trial motion, whereas summary judgment is a pre-trial motion. JMOL is referred to as a motion for a directed verdict in some state courts.

Conclusion

Summary judgments are frequently used by attorneys as a scare tactic because they are notoriously difficult to win. If the party seeking summary judgment is successful, the case is dismissed. Employing competent attorneys in the required practice areas is crucial to winning summary judgments.

  • The judge will decide whether to dismiss the case immediately following the summary judgment or to schedule a trial.
  • The judge can grant conditional orders, rule in the claimant’s favor, or deny the request according to the facts of the case.
  • The trial will be over once the summary judgment has been granted, so you won’t have to deal with the pressures of a full trial.
  • While responding to a summary judgment, you need to file a motion and a memorandum.
  • Working with a skilled summary judgment law firm will help you improve your chances of winning, whether you’re the plaintiff or the defendant.

After reading this article, we hope you get a brief idea of summary judgments and your probability of winning the same.

5/5 - (5 votes)
Divorce & Finance