How To Win a Custody Modification Case After Divorce

Photo of author

By Divorce & Finance

How to win a custody modification case all you need to knowIf you want to know how to win a custody modification case, your parenting plans will have to undergo a big change. The judge will have to decide on the case, and the court’s primary objective in a custody modification case is to establish that the modification serves the child’s best interests.

The court must consider the suitability of each parent, the child’s emotional and physical health, and prospects for a good education and enjoyment.

The jury will rule in your favor if sufficient evidence shows that switching custody would be better for the child’s overall well-being, so learn more on how to win a custody modification case here.

Understanding How You Can Win a Custody Modification Case

You can win a custody modification case by convincing the court that the changes you want to make will significantly improve your child’s life. The case outcome will depend on what the court determines to be in the child’s best interest.

– Custody Modification

Custody modification is a legally recognized modification to the custody arrangement. The statement can translate to numerous things. For instance, you may alter the custody arrangement to make it more equitable or even to give yourself more rights if your spouse is acting in ways that are not in the best interests of your children.

You will spend more time with your children alone if you must have supervised visitation. If your situation has changed or your children spend more time with you, it might also involve issuing a child support order.

For example, Alabama courts use the ex parte Mclendon standard when changing child custody in cases where the parents have divorced but have joint legal custody. Ex parte McLendon, a 1984 case, set a precedent in Alabama. According to the standard, if you want to change the child’s custody, you must demonstrate the following to get it:

  • A change in custody will be in the child’s best interests
  • There has been a material change in circumstances since the last custody ruling
  • The advantages of changing custody will outweigh the disadvantages by a wide margin

Such a rigid rule is intended to prevent unnecessary trouble from arising from changes in custody. The Alabama divorce courts believe stability over change is generally better for children. It is difficult to meet the burden because it is insufficient to demonstrate that the child would benefit from a change in custody. If you want to change custody, you must also show that the change will improve the child’s situation and be worth the hassle it will cause.

– Process of Modifying Child Custody

If you want to modify a custody or visitation order, you must submit a petition to the appropriate court. The petition should generally include the following:

  • The proposed terms of the change
  • The reason you want to change things
  • The names and addresses of both parents
  • A copy of the current custody or visitation order

You must sign the petition and submit it to the court clerk handling your case. There might be a filing fee, but the sum will differ. You should be aware of these guidelines as some courts may require you to attach a form petition or a particular form. The other parent or their attorney must receive the petition too.

If you have legal representation, your attorney can draft and submit the petition on your behalf to ensure that it is completed correctly and contains all the required paperwork.

The court will then ordinarily schedule a hearing date before making a decision. You’ll be able to support your position with evidence and argue for it. The other parent will also have the opportunity to comment in writing and present their case in person during the hearing.

After reviewing all the information, the judge will determine whether or not the change is in your child’s best interests. The court may act more quickly and issue temporary orders to remove the child from the home if there is a claim of child abuse to keep the child safe until the petition is heard and the case is resolved.

There are different processes to ensure you win your custody modification case. These include preparing for the case, taking action, and gathering the necessary documentation.

– Preparing for a Custody Dispute Case

As you can see, to succeed in a custody modification case, you must convince the judge that a change in custody will be in your child’s best interests. Gathering all this information might take some time, but a solid foundation is necessary for a successful outcome. Below are various tips on how to organize evidence for a custody case:

  • Gather evidence of your co-parent’s errors to present in court if you feel they are not up to par. Observe everything they did to endanger or hurt the child.
  • Keep a record of every call or visit your child makes to you. This will demonstrate how close you are to the child or, if your visitation rights are being violated, how you are being kept away from him/her.
  • Observe changes in your child’s behavior, emotions, and academic performance. Any adverse changes should be noted in a way that can be proven in court.
  • Try to avoid having direct disagreements with your ex-partner. Ensure you handle all conflicts respectfully to demonstrate your character and ability to care for your child. Your attorney can serve as a mediator and assist you in coming to a compromise if you cannot communicate properly.
  • Ensure your child has a secure, stable, and loving home to demonstrate to the court that you are prepared for the suggested custody changes.
  • Ensure that your family law attorney or legal team has access to all the information related to your case and any supporting documentation. Your attorney will easily assist you with your case and prepare for it if they have all the information.

Although a solid foundation is crucial for developing your case in court, there is one thing to remember. Family courts favor stability because they believe switching custody is difficult for the child. Therefore, gathering and presenting your evidence in a way that demonstrates a pattern of behavior should be your primary objective. Typically, one adverse event involving the other parent will only sufficiently tip the balance in your favor.

– Succeeding in a Custody Modification Case

You must be prepared to take a few actions to win your motion to modify child custody in your favor. These actions include:

  • Demonstrate your responsibility and interest: You can demonstrate to the court that you are a good parent who cares about your child by being responsible with finances and other factors.
  • Spend time with your child: When caring for your child, spend as much time as possible with them. Try to attend as many of your child’s appointments as possible, and plan to do enjoyable things together too.
  • Be flexible: Your schedule and plans may change due to unanticipated events. You need to adjust your plans with the parenting time.
  • Keep a spotless record: Avoid breaking the law when pursuing a child custody modification A straightforward, preventable crime can damage your reputation and make it more difficult to obtain custody in the future.
  • Take profound notes: Keep a record of your activities and the child support payments you make. Observe any changes in your child’s health or academic progress. Maintaining organization and meticulous records of your child’s activities is crucial in demonstrating that you are a better parent who deserves custody of your child.
  • Ensure your child’s safety at home: You must provide a secure home environment if you want to win a custody dispute.
  • Keep your house clean: Although no one’s home is perfect, keep it tidy when your child is home. Try to limit the number of dirty dishes and unattended spills, as it is essential to determine whether you deserve custody or not.

– Supporting Documents

It’s critical to keep track of all your child’s documents and records if you want to prevail in a custody dispute. Maintain thorough records of everything and have them prepared for the court. Some of the documents that might help in your child custody modification case include the following:

  • Written submission: Be specific about what you want in your court statement. You should outline your argument and provide supporting data when submitting your written statement.
  • Phone call records: Observe any phone or online conversations your child has with the other parent. Keep a record of the duration, frequency, and precise dates and times as well.
  • Visitation dates and times: Precisely note the time and date for visiting your child. How frequently and how long parents visit can reveal how much they value their relationship with their child.
  • Files about your child: While caring for your child, keep track of their assignments, report cards, and anything else that might indicate how well they are doing.

– Child Modification Custody Attorney

You should request legal counsel and help when seeking to change custody. A child modification custody attorney will:

  • Describe the process for changing a child custody order
  • Find out if you are likely to receive a change or how to react to a change request
  • Gather the appropriate forms and complete the paperwork
  • Represent you in court

– Consideration of the Court

Before making a final decision, a court will carefully review all the evidence. The child’s environment at home is crucial as the jury is concerned about the kid’s well-being, security, happiness, and attire. It also considers the personalities and stability of both parents. It might view you as a trustworthy provider if you maintain a consistent income, regular working hours, and stable romantic relationships.

Additionally, the court will take into account your willingness to cooperate. Even though it might seem impossible, the courts always favor those who are willing to co-parent. Lastly, the court will decide whether you are an excessive drug or alcohol taker. You may be required to submit to a drug test to prove that you are not using drugs.

Whatever criteria the court employs, it must consider what is best for the child when determining whether or not to change custody. It will examine the testimony and evidence presented regarding the matters above. The objective is to provide the child with a secure, loving environment where they can develop while maintaining strong, positive bonds with both parents.

– Changes in Child Custody May Impact Child Support

You should consult a lawyer about your current child support order if your child’s custody changes. It may be necessary to ask the court to reduce your obligation if you pay child support but spend more time with your child, but this isn’t always possible.

If you have already paid support but are spending less time with your child, the other parent may request additional funds from you. You could receive child support instead if you gained custody after previously not having it. You should consult a lawyer to return to court and modify the child support order.

Grounds for Child Custody Modification

The grounds for child custody modification that the judges will take into consideration include factors such as if your child is prone to risk, the presence of substantial changes in circumstances, or the death of a custodial parent, among others.

You can’t just win a custody dispute by claiming that you want to change things because it’s more convenient for you. The court system can be stringent regarding the justifications for why a custody plan should and can be changed. Judges know that people’s requirements and circumstances change, but there are ways to safeguard the best interests of both parents and children.

Not to mention that making changes on the spot might cause the already backed-up legal system to take longer. Therefore, proving that you have the proper motives is the first step in winning your case to change custody. Here are the grounds for custody modification:

– Your Child Is Prone to Risk

A risk is among the best justifications for switching custody of a child. The courts can change things if your child is in danger when they are with your ex. This typically entails obtaining a protective court order against your ex. The judge may then alter the custody arrangement in your favor after that.

It is crucial to remember that this is typically not a long-term or permanent solution and will generally be reviewed periodically. Typically, this is only done in blatant risks such as physical, mental, or sexual abuse or risky personal behaviors. If you don’t have a compelling reason to go this route, you shouldn’t.

– Presence of Substantial Change in Circumstances

The most frequent justification for a change in custody is a significant change in circumstances. So what is a substantial change in circumstance for custody? The situation might result from a parent’s recent diagnosis of a severe mental illness or their use of drugs or alcohol.

There should also be sufficient evidence to conclude that one parent neglected or mistreated the child, contributing to the child’s deteriorating health. Another frequent occurrence is when a parent must relocate due to their employment. If this occurs, you can request sole custody or a custody plan based on months rather than days of the week.

– Death of the Custodial Parent

You should request a child custody change if the primary custodial parent passes away. The court will determine whether you will assume primary custody or if a third party will do so. For the child’s convenience, the court typically prefers that the youngster remains with you. However, it will consider other options if the kid cannot stay with you for one of the following reasons:

  • You cannot assume the child’s complete responsibility because of your line of work
  • The kid does not want to live with you but prefers a third party.How to win a custody modification case what to expect


If you are composed, remain organized, and put in a lot of effort, you will have a good chance of obtaining the custody modification you require in your favor. The success of your case will depend on various things, and in this article, you have learned about the multiple aspects of a custody modification case, including:

  • Gathering evidence, filing a petition, keeping a good record, and seeking legal help is the key to winning a custody modification case.
  • You can request a custody change if the custodial co-parent is negligent, incapacitated, or has passed away.
  • The process to modify custody involves filing a petition and attending court proceedings for a verdict.
  • Make sure you are prepared for the court and that you have all the necessary documents and proof of your claims. This will help strengthen you case and your chances of approval.

You should also speak with an expert family law attorney from an established law firm if you want to win a custody modification case, because an attorney can advise you on whether to take action immediately or wait until you have sufficient evidence to support your petition. Your divorce attorney can also assist you in developing additional strategies for trying to modify child custody.

5/5 - (17 votes)
Divorce & Finance